All blogs are property of authors and copying is not permitted.

Sunday, November 10, 2013


By R. Ann Siracusa
This started out to be a simple little blog about being thankful on Thanksgiving. However, because I was born lacking the pithy gene, I decided to do some research on the holiday.

Big Mistake!

I found a number of conflicting "historic facts" and a myriad of versions of each. What a bummer!
We all know the story about the Pilgrims of the Plymouth Colony celebrating their first year in the New World in the fall of 1621. Unfortunately, only half of them survived the year.

When I was in school (back in the dark ages), we were taught that was the first Thanksgiving. I didn't know that the Plymouth Colony is in competition as the first "American Thanksgiving" with two locations in Texas, two in Florida, one in Maine, two in Virginia, and five in Massachusetts.
Who knew?

I didn't realize there were that many colonies and expeditions before 1621. Also, I noticed that the article didn't list where those sites were located or who made the claims.

Two sources indicated that the first known Thanksgiving feast in North America was celebrated in Palo Duro Canyon (Texas panhandle) in 1541 by Francisco Vásquez de Coronado and the "Tejas" of the Hasinai group of Caddo-speaking Native Americans.

In 1565, another Spanish explorer, Pedro Menéndez de Avilé and his expedition hosted the local Timucua tribe at a celebration dinner in St. Augustine, Florida. The festivities included a mass to thank God for their safe arrival.

Thirty-eight British settlers proclaimed their day of arrival at Berkeley Hundred, a location on Virginia's James River, as "a day of thanksgiving" on December 4, 1619.
The history of harvest festivals goes back thousands of years. It's a natural time to celebrate, particularly when the harvest has been good, and it marks the change of seasons. The Plymouth Colony celebration in 1621 must have had its roots in the ancient harvest festivals. At that time, England and other parts of Europe already set aside days to give thanks to God.

But how did Thanksgiving become an official holiday? And how did Mary and her lamb get into this?

George Washing, John Adams, and James Madison called Americans to observe various period of thanksgiving but there was no specific date. Sometimes the celebrations weren't even in the fall. President Jefferson called a federal holiday as "the most ridiculous idea ever conceived."

Sarah Joespha Hale (1788-1879), a magazine editor and the author of poems including "Mary Had A Little Lamb", campaigned for twenty years to make Thanksgiving a national holiday. Her campaign spanned five presidents.

Finally, in 1863, Hale convinced President Lincoln to proclaim Thanksgiving as a national holiday on a specific date. He thought it would help unite the country after the Civil War. From that day on, until it was set into US law in 1941, Thanksgiving was proclaimed annually the current president.

By the way, Sarah Hale deserves attention she may not be getting in history lessons. She also was the first person to advocate women as teachers in public schools, the first to advocate day nurseries to assist working mothers, and the first to propose public playgroups. She is the author of two dozen books and hundreds of poems, including "Mary Had A Little Lamb."

I don't remember studying Sarah Hale at all in school, but I found a number of high schools named after her..

When it comes to articles about Thanksgiving, for some reason the major topic of concern focuses on food. What happened to topics like freedom and valuing what you have?
Green Bean Casserole
The most "significant fact" I learned was this. More than forty million green bean casseroles are served on Thanksgiving. Heavy! And green bean casserole is only fifty (fifty-three?) years old. It was created in 1955 by the Campbell Soup Company.
Does that rock your boat, or what? 

Cranberry Sauce
The cranberry is a staple of the modern Thanksgiving feast. It is served at 94% of all Thanksgiving dinners. It was originally called "crane berry" because its pink blossoms and drooping head reminded the Pilgrims of a crane. No one explained why it's called a "sauce."

Native Americans didn't eat cranberries, but used them for dying fabric, decorating pottery, and treating arrow wounds. Several sources indicated that cranberries are one of the few fruits (one source said three) native to North America. Wikipedia, however, lists a large number of fruits native to North America but says, "However, only three are commercially grown/known on a global scale (grapes, cranberries, and blueberries.)"

Regardless, cranberries were not on the Thanksgiving menu in 1621.

Another earthshaking fact: You can tell if a cranberry is ripe by throwing it at the ground and measuring how high it bounces. And even more incredible, the source claims, "As long as it bounces higher than four inches, it is ready to be picked."

The operative words: Ready to be picked. Help me out here. How the heck do you throw the cranberry to the ground and bounce it, if it hasn't been picked yet?
Some say yes, some say no, others say yes, but a totally different type of turkey. Most sources claim the main foods were probably venison and sea foods.

First, it seemed as though most of the articles I found were out to debunk as many Thanksgiving traditions as they can. Sure, the holiday has evolved. The menu has evolved. What difference does it make? The purpose of the holiday and what Americans are supposed to commemorate was established when it was made a federal holiday. What we eat doesn't matter. Forgetting to be thankful and count our blessings does matter.

Second, if the information about other "first thanksgivings" is available, why isn't it taught in school? Why don't they teach about Sarah Hale? [My grandkids ranging from 26 to 3 have never heard of her.] Why do they tell kids the pilgrims ate cranberries if they didn't?

Third, why all this emphasis on food? Aren't we already a nation of overweight people?

One of my friends received a bracelet with four large beads as a gift. The instructions are to wear the bracelet all the time. Every morning when you put it on, say aloud four things you are thankful for each bead. When you look at it during the day, say again four other things you are thankful for.

It doesn't take very long to discover that we each have more in our lives to be grateful for than we thought [which may or may not include cranberry sauce, green bean casserole, fat domesticated turkeys, pumpkin pie, and football].

Thanksgiving shouldn't be just one day a year when we count our blessing.



Melissa Keir said...

I had heard of Sarah Hale but that's because I did a search on her in school. :)

But I agree about's not what it's become (commercialized) or about the past (we were the first) but about the connections we make to family, thankfulness, our life and happiness. We would be so much better off with a little less "things" and a little more happiness!

<3 Happy Early Thanksgiving!

Cara Marsi said...

Very interesting. Thanks. I'd never heard of Sarah Hale before this. Your blog made me hungry.

Nicole Morgan said...

Being a huge history geek I loved your post! PLUS, all that talking about some of my favorite Thanksgiving feasts made me hungry. Now, I am going to be counting down the days! :)

jean hart stewart said...

Good to know about Sarah Hale. Thought I knew my history but she's new to me...

Sandy said...

R.Ann, I haven't laughed so hard in a while. I agree with all you had to say, and that's saying a lot because it's not often I don't usually with anyone totally. lol An excellent post, R. Ann.

Paris said...

Interesting post. I know the holidays have become commercialized but Thanksgiving has always been one of those times that my family celebrated their ethnic roots with food. We may have had a traditional turkey and dressing but there was also Polish Sausage and Povitica (nut bread). No green bean casserole, though:) There is quite an emphasis on food but I think we might be able to track that back to leaner times-- the war years, the depression, the dust bowl--and the generations were influenced by that time.

I have to agree with you about how the schools don't teach history anymore.

Suzanne Rock said...

Interesting post! All of that talk about food made me hungry, lol. Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday. I think it's so important to take a step back from life and be thankful for all your blessings. Thanks so much for sharing.

Share buttons